I wrote this article for the September 2012 issue of Pacific Fishing. Pick it up at newsstands, or if you’re not in a fishing community on the Pacific Coast of the the US, check it out here.

PF_logo_trans2For decades there has been no footwear more ubiquitous to commercial fishing in the North Pacific than Xtratuf boots. From San Diego to the Bering Sea, fishermen have relied on their durability, comfort, and support as a consistent tool for the trade. Xtratuf has built a near monopoly with their well-crafted, fully waterproof uppers and slip-resistant soles, giving them a steady, inelastic demand. In my short four years commercial fishing, I have never seen anyone wear anything but Xtratufs.

At the start of this year’s Southeast Alaska seine season, I picked up a new pair after my old pair succumbed to the grind of near daily use fishing for salmon and Dungies for a year and a half. I noticed something was a little different, the boots lacked the classic oily residue, and the logo was without the “Made in USA” and red, white, and blue patriotic banner.

At the end of 2011, Honeywell—the giant conglomerate that purchased the Xtratuf brand in 2008—closed its plant in Rock Island, Ill., where Xtratufs have been made since the 1970s, and moved production to an existing Honeywell facility in China. In the process, 250 to 300 people lost their jobs, as David Pauley, mayor of Rock Island, told Alaska’s KACW.

Honeywell decided to move production because the Rock Island factory was no longer efficient and could not keep up with production demands, according to an official statement from the company.

Beyond abandoning American workers, the move in and of itself wouldn’t necessarily change things. One would assume a neoprene boot triple dipped in rubber would be the same whether produced in the United States or China, but this seems not to be the case.

After about a week, the band that adheres uppers to the sole on one of my boots started to peel; after three weeks, the band began to significantly come off to the point where I could see a two-inch-long gap between the sole and the uppers. The same thing happened to my crewmate, who had recently purchased a pair. While anecdotal evidence isn’t enough to condemn a product as inferior, further investigation shows that Xtratuf’s shoddy craftsmanship is widespread.

“The quality went to crap,” said Dan Voelz, the manager of Murray Pacific in Ketchikan. “Commercial fishermen are a unique breed. When they go out, they’re out for a long time. They need equipment that they know they can depend on, and these don’t cut it.”

That’s quite the statement, especially coming from someone who makes money selling the product.

At Murray Pacific, the number of returns for Xtratuf products has increased markedly. “In just a few months this year, we’ve had more returns than all of last year,” Voelz added.

Murray Pacific isn’t alone in retailer disappointed with Xtratufs.

“The quality is definitely not there,” said Jodi Ficele, footwear manager at Tongass Trading Co. in Ketchikan. “We have a lot of frustrated customers and a lot more returns.”

The problem lies not in a change in materials, but in workmanship, said Steve Haynes, the Anchorage-based sales representative for Xtratufs. “These boots are very labor intensive,” Haynes said. “There’s almost no automation in the construction of Xtratufs.” He went on to say that there was a steep leaning curve for workers in China, who didn’t apply adequate amounts of adhesive, but that the problems have been addressed and corrected this spring.

“I’ve been doing a lot of damage control the past month,” he said. “We’re doing everything we can do short of a recall.”

That doesn’t seem to do much about the thousands of shoddy boots already purchased and the remaining stocks on retailers’ shelves. I, for one, bought my defective boots in Seattle before coming up to Alaska, and I am unable to return them. If I were to buy a new pair, I don’t have much faith that I wouldn’t get stuck with boots from the first runs of Chinese production. At this point, I don’t think a recall would be asking too much. To add insult to injury, the company had not passed on its reduced labor costs to consumers. In fact, the cost per pair of boots has actually increased by a few dollars since last year, noted Voelz.

“Buy American” is hardly a thought when it comes to gear worn by commercial fishermen in the U.S. Grundéns is a Swedishcompany, with most of its rain gear manufactured in Portugal. Guy Cotton is French and produced in France. Atlas gloves are made in Malaysia. All the same, it is sad to see American production end, and it’s frustrating to see such a decrease in quality, even if it is temporary.

“People keep asking me for a replacement,” said Voelz. “And I don’t think it will take long for one to hit the market.”

He just might be on to something. Bogs, a footwear manufacturer specializing in waterproof boots, will release the Highliner Pro in early 2013 to give Xtratuf greater competition in the commercial fishing market, said a spokesperson for the company.

Xtratuf has also announced the release of Xtratuf II, a new boot that adds the warmth and comfort of Muck Boots, also a subsidiary of Honeywell, with the durability and oil-chemical resistance of the now-renamed Xtratuf Legacy.

Beyond the fact that Xtratuf is engrained in the cultural identity of fishing communities—being spotted with dresses, at weddings, and worn in the Alaskan State Capital—competitors have yet to come up with a product that works as good as Xtratuf. Now that Xtratuf finds itself with many frustrated former loyal customers, Bogs stands a good chance to erode Xtratuf’s market dominance if their product can meet the exacting demands of commercial fishermen.

11 responses to “Xtratuf: Now in China and selling shoddy boots”

  1. JuneauTek Avatar

    Reblogged this on JuneauTek and commented:
    Nice insight! My new pair were separating by the end of one summer of salmon seining.

  2. badfish Avatar

    Well unfortunately Honeywell set the standard (which may have been lower) to make them cheaper to produce in china. China does make cheap stuff…but on the other hand they are limited by the parameters that companies give them to produce things.

  3. Enough About Hooked… How are YOU? « Hooked Avatar

    […] family making the transition from crew to captain! Nick Rahaim, great Pacific Fishing article on Xtra Tuf’s shoddy sell-out to China – what are you working on […]

  4. Fred H Avatar
    Fred H

    What I say is don’t support this, I will never again buy a pair of their boots….period end of story!…There are other companies making rubber boots here, as stated other’s will fill this niche…. I will support them!

  5. Southeast Alaska Avatar
    Southeast Alaska

    CLEAR difference in QUALITY!!! Me and a lot of other people in and from ALASKA are not happy at all….I will hang on to my Made in the USA XTRATUFS but after these….no more!
    I took a friend of mine to buy some new tufs not knowing they changed…and you could see and feel the difference immediately! I’m pretty sure I could have ripped the new ones apart with my bare hands if I tried!! but instead we ended up at the Alaskan Walking Co, I say BAD MOVE on XtraTuf co…..I know a lot of folks in Southeast AK who will no longer buy this book or support the company!

  6. Anthony Avatar

    Bought them for myself and family but no more! Sham on you Honeywell! Just glad I have a few old new “Made in USA” ones in boxes in the garage. When those go I guess it will be time to start looking elsewhere.

  7. […] Bog boots going to be the next big thing in the commercial fishing world? After the fact that the renowned company Xtratuf is moving its operations to China, there may be avoid waiting to be filled in the boot world. Xtratuf is a company that dominated the […]

  8. Jay Follman Avatar

    Nick, Did I miss where Bogs manufactures it’s products? I am adamant about purchasing US products. This type of nonsense frustrates me. Thanks for the information. I have 3 pairs of XT’s 2 in reserve. Hope they don’t dry out!!
    Jay Follman

    1. Nick Rahaim Avatar

      Well, it turns out that most of Bogs boots are manufactured in China too. Although, when I spoke with representatives from Bogs last year they said they were planning on bringing manufacturing of their most popular boots back to Oregon.

  9. wycliffe nichol Avatar
    wycliffe nichol

    Same issue with La Cross boots they sent their manufacturing over to China and now produce a garbage product, I think its time to reopen there old facilities here without their management and start making quality products again. Leave all of these companies crap boots on the shelf and let China recycle its own crap quality boots. Companies who have moved offshore to make money for their stockholders need to be taught a lesson in economics……Refuse to buy poor quality ill fitting Chinese junk to put in our dumps.

    Wycliffe Nichol…Ontario Canada

  10. Ron williams Avatar
    Ron williams

    I have a pair of muck duck boots for the last 25 years now I have brought 6 pair of the short boots and the 30 below hunting boots the soles come off before a year noticed they are made in china also

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: